politics

The debate comes after nearly two months of social mobilization

Outside the Senate, protesters denounce a bill that presumes police use of weapons to be lawful, while the left delays the vote this evening amid protests.

reportage, présomption, sénat, luxembourg, andr, police, ordre, forces

Key facts

  • The protest takes place against a backdrop of investigations already under way. The Defender of Rights announced yesterday that it had received 106…
  • The debate comes after nearly two months of social mobilization. Dozens of associations gathered to protest the adoption of the bill as senators discuss it.
  • Its supporters argue that it reverses the burden of proof and that it will provide additional legal protection for police officers.

The protest takes place against a backdrop of investigations already under way. The Defender of Rights announced yesterday that it had received 106 complaints implicating the police, including 39 for armed violence. The IGPN, the police watchdog, announced at the end of October that it had opened 83 inquiries.

The debate comes after nearly two months of social mobilization. Dozens of associations gathered to protest the adoption of the bill as senators discuss it.

Its supporters argue that it reverses the burden of proof and that it will provide additional legal protection for police officers.

Legal expert Sébastien Tüller disputes this interpretation. According to him,"it is up to the State to show that the use of force is appropriate, necessary and proportionate.".

Thirty-five white stelae were erected in front of a block of earth. They represent the victims of fatal police shootings since 2017. Around these symbolic graves, the demonstrators walk calmly.

Microphone in hand, women speakers each took their turn to denounce the bill as well as its assault on the rule of law.

The Senate left is massively opposed to the bill. According to the senator from the Rhône,"the enemies of the Republic are those who will vote for this text.".

Dig deeper

What is the Defender of Rights?

An independent authority responsible for ensuring respect for rights and freedoms, it can be referred to by private individuals, including for acts attributed to law enforcement.

What is the IGPN?

The General Inspectorate of the National Police, often called the "police of the police," investigates officers' conduct and can open disciplinary or judicial proceedings.

What does the reversal of the burden of proof mean in this debate?

Its supporters want it no longer to be up to the State to demonstrate that the use of force was appropriate, necessary and proportionate, which the jurist Sébastien Tüller disputes.

Why is the Rhône mentioned?

The Rhône is a department whose prefecture is Lyon; one of its senators, not named in the text, opposes the bill on behalf of the Senate left.

What is at stake?

The text promises greater legal protection for police officers, while associations and the Senate left see it as an attack on the rule of law after nearly two months of mobilization.

Lire en français