politics

Senate: suspension of debates on the legal use of weapons

The Senate on Thursday evening suspended consideration of a bill on the presumption of lawful use of weapons by law enforcement, after sharp tensions.

italie, mussolini, sénat, chambre, qualifiée, texte, forces, ordre

Key facts

  • After these tumultuous exchanges, the discussion was suspended overnight. Senators are due to resume on Friday at 5 p.m. During the day, the upper…
  • The Senate began on Thursday afternoon, in a highly charged atmosphere, its examination of the bill on the use of weapons by law enforcement.…
  • Such an outcome would end the parliamentary shuttle and open the way to swift promulgation. The government had been counting on a vote late in the…

After these tumultuous exchanges, the discussion was suspended overnight. Senators are due to resume on Friday at 5 p.m. During the day, the upper house is also examining the finance bill for 2027.

The Senate began on Thursday afternoon, in a highly charged atmosphere, its examination of the bill on the use of weapons by law enforcement. Senators were unable to complete the text: the debate was suspended at 12:30 a.m.

Such an outcome would end the parliamentary shuttle and open the way to swift promulgation. The government had been counting on a vote late in the evening. The exchanges, marked by very sharp tensions between the left and the right, prevented that timetable.

The issue is not the creation of a new ground for opening fire. Contrary to what its original title suggests, the text does not create any additional authority for police officers or gendarmes to use weapons.

In its initial version, the bill provided for a presumption of self-defense for law enforcement. The legal difficulties associated with that wording led the government to rewrite the entire text during the debates in the National Assembly.

The bill leads to a reversal of the burden of proof. It is no longer up to the police officer to demonstrate the legality of the shot: it is up to the complainant to provide proof of improper use.

Opening the general discussion, the minister said he had “seen the context in which police officers and gendarmes operate harden very markedly.” He cited “a rise in ultraviolence,” “the unrestrained methods of organized crime,” and “a crisis of authority” of which the internal security forces would be “both the emergency responders and the victims.”.

Initially, this group intended to place the text on its parliamentary niche agenda, before the executive took it up itself. The left, firmly opposed, tried to have three motions of rejection adopted in the afternoon, then multiplied speeches and explanations of vote to delay the ballot.

Late in the evening, the debate became bogged down in a battle of figures. The left asserts that fatal shootings by police officers or gendarmes have increased fivefold in recent years, a tally disputed by Laurent Nuñez. The examination comes in an autumn marked by high-school mobilizations and protests against the cost of living, punctuated by violence in several cities.

Dig deeper

What is the Senate, also called the upper house?

It is the second chamber of the French Parliament: it examines and may amend texts that have been passed or are under consideration in the National Assembly before they become law.

What is the parliamentary shuttle?

It is the back-and-forth of the same text between the National Assembly and the Senate until an agreement is reached; if it is identical in both chambers, promulgation can follow quickly.

What does the reversal of the burden of proof mean in this text?

The police officer would no longer have to demonstrate himself the legality of his shot: it would be up to the complainant to provide proof of improper use, without creating a new case for opening fire.

Why does the National Assembly matter in this case?

That is where the government rewrote the entire proposal, after legal difficulties linked to a presumption of self-defense provided for in the initial draft.

What happens next?

Senators are to resume on Friday at 5 p.m.; during the day, the upper house is also examining the finance bill for 2027.

Lire en français