The first set was over almost before it had started. Alcaraz led 6-2 without showing his full range. His drop shot and net play were largely unused.
The Spaniard broke in the first game and again in the third. Tiafoe struggled to land his first serve and did little with his second.
Alcaraz said he had never felt this energised at this point in the season, after time away from competition.
He has never had a year like this one, with months off the tour. He arrived with energy and hungry for more.
He did raise his level a little in the second set and tried to play with more aggression.
It was not enough. He was broken for 2-1, then failed to take three break-back points and slipped to 4-2.
Alcaraz answered from the back of the court. A forehand guided down the line gave him a second double break and kept the set one-sided.
Tiafoe had his moments. He forced deuce on the Alcaraz serve and won long rallies, only to miss when the point turned against him.
Alcaraz also showed the gap on second serve, following a heavy delivery with a winner and then a violent cross-court forehand.
He closed the match on serve. Tiafoe read the delivery, moved wide to return, and framed the shot.
The afternoon was a chastening start for the debutant. Alcaraz did not need every shot he owns, and still left little doubt about his appetite after a long layoff.