He is back after a four-month layoff with a wrist injury. Since his return at the US Open in August, he has won three titles and lost twice in 23 matches.
The Spaniard hit 21 winners and made nine unforced errors in a 69-minute match, dismantling Tiafoe from the baseline.
"This is the best that I felt so far in my career at this part of the season,"the former world number one said.
Alcaraz, 23, took the first set in 27 minutes. He lost one point on serve and made two unforced errors in that set.
He also denied Tiafoe three break points at 3-2 in the second set, mixing baseline control with athleticism and shot-making.
Tiafoe, the American, put 74% of his first serves in but did not win a point on his second serve, going 0 for 12.
"It was unusual for me to have a lot of months out of competition and it means I'm coming here with a lot of energy and ambition,"Alcaraz said.
The ATP Finals is the season-ending event for the year's eight top-performing men's players.
Alcaraz reached the title match at the tournament for the first time last year.