This increase is explained in part by inflation over the past decade. It also reflects changes in the number of judicial proceedings and the emergence of new types of litigation. For the Senate, the additional 4% in appropriations entered by the government is not enough to make up this shortfall.
The Senate broadens the finding beyond the facilities. In 2024, France had 11.6 judges per 100,000 inhabitants, compared with a median of 23.4 judges for all European Union countries.
The upper house warns in particular about the gap between the rise in the number of people incarcerated and the number of new prison places. Justice appropriations are nonetheless among the few portfolios set to increase in 2027, amid budgetary austerity.
Pressure on the prison estate is at the center of the report. Between 1 October 2025 and 1 October 2026, the number of inmates rose by 6,075, reaching 89,400 people excluding the overseas territories.
Over the same period, only 951 new places could be created. The mismatch between admissions and available capacity shapes the Senate's warning.
The average occupancy rate stands at 178.9%. It can exceed 200% in some facilities. The report is particularly alarmed by this pressure on the estate.
The Senate nonetheless welcomes the efforts undertaken since 2025 to reduce construction times. It cites modular prisons and the fitting-out of wings specifically dedicated to organized crime.
Procedural delays reflect this falling behind. Listing for hearing or judgment at first instance before the civil and commercial courts takes nearly twice as long in France as the European average. At second instance, in criminal matters, the delay is 3.8 times longer.
The report also criticizes the overly slow growth of staffing in the regions, despite the stated targets. Vacancy rates there stand between 7.0% and 11.2%.