world

They said they responded to terrorist actions by Rohingya militants

Judges at the UN's top court are weighing whether Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya in a case The Gambia brought, with no right of appeal.

myanmar, rohingya, genocide convention, however, rohingyas, genocide, court, verdict

Key facts

  • Since she was deposed by a coup in 2021 and placed under arrest, the defence has been led by a new team appointed by the military. Myanmar's lawyers…
  • The question before the UN's top court is whether discrimination, official rhetoric and the violence that followed amounted to genocide.
  • The case accuses the state of Myanmar, not only its armed forces. Myanmar authorities have denied accusations of ethnic cleansing or genocide.

Since she was deposed by a coup in 2021 and placed under arrest, the defence has been led by a new team appointed by the military. Myanmar's lawyers and Suu Kyi have argued on similar lines.

The question before the UN's top court is whether discrimination, official rhetoric and the violence that followed amounted to genocide.

The case accuses the state of Myanmar, not only its armed forces. Myanmar authorities have denied accusations of ethnic cleansing or genocide.

Suleman said what was presented to the court was"the long history of discrimination targeting the Rohingya, and how that history, and the policies connected with it, provide a background to understand the government's language, rhetoric, propaganda, and policies that were part of the 2017 'clearance operations'.".

A UN report in 2018, based on hundreds of interviews, said the army's tactics were"grossly disproportionate to actual security threats". Many Rohingya villages have been completely destroyed.

Aung San Suu Kyi said The Gambia's team mischaracterised a complex conflict and military operation. She accepted that war crimes may have been committed against the Rohingya, but said that was not proof of genocidal intent.

Historically, proving that genocide has been committed has been very difficult. Where there is no explicitly genocidal programme, like that of the Nazis, judges typically require that the only reasonable inference from the defendants' actions is genocidal intent.

No state has ever been found guilty by an international court of committing genocide. There is no right of appeal against an ICJ verdict, and no penalty follows one.

The ICJ was established in 1945 to help settle disputes between states, not to try international crimes. It was chosen to address the attacks on the Rohingya because there were few other avenues of redress for the victims.

The Gambia's move was a novelty in international law: a state not directly affected argued that it had standing because it was indirectly affected by any violation of so important a convention. Myanmar objected, but the judges ruled that The Gambia was eligible to file the case.

More than a million are stuck in wretched camps in Bangladesh, barred from employment as international funding dries up. International support for them has faded over the years.

Even an unprecedented genocide verdict at the world's highest court cannot change that reality.

Dig deeper

Who are the Rohingya?

They are a mostly Muslim minority long based in western Myanmar. The state has denied most of them citizenship, and many fled after villages were destroyed in the 2017 military campaign.

Who is Aung San Suu Kyi?

She was Myanmar's civilian leader until the 2021 coup put her under arrest. She defended the state before the UN court, accepting that war crimes may have occurred but rejecting genocidal intent.

What is the court hearing this case?

It is the International Court of Justice, the UN's top court for disputes between states. It must decide whether Myanmar's discrimination, rhetoric and violence against the Rohingya amounted to genocide.

What is The Gambia's role?

The Gambia brought the case against the state of Myanmar, not only its armed forces, arguing that long-running discrimination and the 2017 operations show genocidal intent.

What were the 2017 clearance operations?

That is Myanmar's name for the military campaign in Rohingya areas, which authorities framed as a response to militant attacks. A 2018 UN report called the army's tactics grossly disproportionate to the security threat.

Why is a genocide finding so hard?

Without an explicit extermination programme, judges usually require that genocidal intent is the only reasonable inference from a state's actions. No state has ever been found guilty of genocide by an international court, and an ICJ verdict brings no penalty and no appeal.

Lire en français