On 17 November, senators adopted Article 37 of the Social Security financing bill (PLFSS) for 2027. The text introduces a requirement of one year of regular residence in France before access to most family benefits for certain non-European Union foreigners.
The provision was included in the bill drafted by the government. It was passed by a show of hands at the end of a stormy debate that occupied much of the sitting, pitting the left against the Senate majority and the executive.
The stakes are first and foremost political. The aim of the article is described as symbolic. In recent years, the Senate right has repeatedly, and unsuccessfully, tried to impose a waiting period for foreigners’ access to non-contributory social benefits, notably family allowances and personal housing assistance (APL).
The measure covers the early childhood benefit (Paje), the back-to-school allowance (ARS), the family supplement, the family support allowance and the APL. It does not apply to all foreigners present on French territory.
Refugees, beneficiaries of subsidiary protection and stateless persons are excluded. The requirement also does not apply to foreigners holding a residence permit authorizing them to work, nor to nationals of countries linked to France by a reciprocity agreement on social rights.
The budgetary yield remains limited for the family branch. The measure is expected to save 1.8 million euros per year. For the state budget, which finances the APL, the reduction in spending would be higher, on the order of 60 million euros a year.
This low yield has fueled incomprehension among many lawmakers, including at times in the center. Several have questioned the point of a provision whose financial effect appears modest relative to the political burden it carries.
The article itself was adopted without difficulty by a show of hands. Only the deletion amendments were put to a public vote, which gives a sense of the balance of power: 206 votes in favor of the article, against 132.
The first-reading debates on the 2027 PLFSS are due to conclude in the evening in the Senate. Explanations of vote and the solemn ballot are scheduled for this Wednesday, after questions to the government.
The Constitutional Council had struck down this provision on the grounds that it was a legislative rider, that is, a measure with no link to the bill. This time, the government recalled that the waiting period is already much longer for two other non-contributory benefits: five years of regular residence permit for the active solidarity income, and ten years for the minimum old-age benefit.
Senators from the National Rally and the UDR tried to toughen the government article by extending the waiting period to three years, or even five years. The text retained remains the one-year version.
The Social Affairs Committee backed the article, in line with the position of the Senate majority expressed for several years. As with previous similar initiatives, the left caused an uproar in the chamber.
A few senators from the Centrist Union or close to Renaissance distanced themselves from the provision. A handful of lawmakers from the right or center-right responded to challenges from the Socialist, Green and Communist groups.