politics

Text changes how police and gendarmerie shootings are examined

Adopted on Friday by Parliament, the text establishes a presumption of lawful use of weapons for police officers and gendarmes, contested on the left.

france, nombre, conseil, parlement, face, présomption, usage, armes

Key facts

  • He recalled that the so-called “Cazeneuve” law of February 2017, which expanded the conditions for the use of weapons by police officers,…
  • The text changes the framework in which shots fired by police officers and gendarmes are examined, while the number of gunshots and the conduct of…
  • As a consequence of this presumption, gendarmes and police officers who have fired a lethal shot will no longer automatically be placed in custody.

He recalled that the so-called “Cazeneuve” law of February 2017, which expanded the conditions for the use of weapons by police officers, particularly in cases of failure to comply, resulted in a fivefold increase in the number of people killed by the police for that reason.

The text changes the framework in which shots fired by police officers and gendarmes are examined, while the number of gunshots and the conduct of investigations after a lethal use of a weapon remain at the heart of the debate.

As a consequence of this presumption, gendarmes and police officers who have fired a lethal shot will no longer automatically be placed in custody.

Opponents consider the measure dangerous for fundamental rights. The Senate left, hostile to the text, announced that it would refer the matter to the Constitutional Council to block its promulgation.

Dig deeper

Who is Bernard Cazeneuve?

Bernard Cazeneuve, a Socialist, served as interior minister and then as prime minister under François Hollande. His name is associated with the February 2017 law that broadened the circumstances in which police officers may use their weapons, notably when faced with a refusal to comply.

What is the so-called Cazeneuve law?

It is the February 2017 law that extended the conditions under which police officers may use their weapons, particularly during a refusal to comply. The text under debate follows on from that framework, which has been criticized for increasing fatal shootings in such situations.

What is the Constitutional Council?

The Constitutional Council checks, before promulgation, that a law complies with the Constitution when it is referred to it by members of Parliament. The Senate left wants to use it to prevent the text from entering into force.

Why does this text matter?

It changes the way shootings by police officers and gendarmes are examined, at a time when the number of shots fired and investigations following a lethal use of force remain contested. Its opponents see in it a risk to fundamental rights.

What does ending automatic placement in police custody change?

After a lethal shooting, police officers and gendarmes would no longer be placed in custody automatically, because of a presumption provided for by the text. This measure is at the heart of the disagreement over oversight of the use of weapons.

Lire en français