politics

Sylvie Robert introduces a bill to guarantee artistic freedom

Socialist Senator Sylvie Robert introduces a bill aimed at strengthening the offense of obstruction and guaranteeing freedom of artistic creation.

sylvie robert, déprogrammations, face, ille, vilaine, sénatrice, liberté, sylvie

Key facts

  • Obstructions take multiple forms: canceled performances, withdrawn works, disrupted events, vandalized bookstores, or cyberharassment campaigns. A…
  • Sylvie Robert nevertheless acknowledges the need to preserve a balance with freedom of expression. Criticizing a work, challenging a program, or…
  • Ten years after helping to enshrine in law the principle that"artistic creation is free,"she believes that the safeguards stemming from the law on…

Obstructions take multiple forms: canceled performances, withdrawn works, disrupted events, vandalized bookstores, or cyberharassment campaigns. A Senate report, an opinion of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council (CESE) adopted in March 2026, and the work of the Observatory of Creative Freedom have documented these infringements.

Sylvie Robert nevertheless acknowledges the need to preserve a balance with freedom of expression. Criticizing a work, challenging a program, or calling for a boycott must remain possible. The opinions of artists, performers, or organizers could no more serve as grounds for an obstruction, unless they amount to offenses provided for by law, notably incitement to hatred or the glorification of terrorism.

Ten years after helping to enshrine in law the principle that"artistic creation is free,"she believes that the safeguards stemming from the law on the freedom of creation, architecture and heritage (LCAP), adopted in 2016, are no longer sufficient.

It is above all the rise of self-censorship that worries her. More insidious than an outright ban, this preventive censorship leads professionals to set aside certain works or certain artists even before a controversy breaks out.

These direct pressures are compounded by budgetary decisions. Some local authorities have reduced or eliminated subsidies for cultural projects, sometimes in the name of financial constraints, but also, the senator denounces, for political or ideological reasons.

The first article of the text targets the offense of obstructing freedom of creation, enshrined in the Criminal Code since 2016. The senator considers the mechanism largely ineffective: it penalizes only pressures that have actually prevented a performance or a creation, a condition that is difficult to establish.

The second article aims to better regulate bans on artistic or cultural events issued by administrative authorities.

Public or subsidized cultural institutions should no longer merely ensure respect for freedom of programming, but"respect and guarantee"it, without exercising ideological, political, or religious censorship. It is also, according to her, a matter of protecting nonprofit cultural actors against pressures linked to the interpretation of this framework.

Dig deeper

Who is Sylvie Robert?

A Socialist senator for Ille-et-Vilaine, she has long followed cultural policy and helped, in 2016, to enshrine in law the principle of freedom of artistic creation.

What is the LCAP law?

The law on freedom of creation, architecture and heritage, adopted in 2016, establishes that artistic creation is free and created an offense of obstruction that the senator now considers insufficient.

What is the Economic, Social and Environmental Council?

The CESE is a consultative assembly of the Republic, distinct from Parliament, which brings together social partners and civil society and adopted in March 2026 an opinion on these infringements.

What is the Observatory of Freedom of Creation?

It is a body that records pressures, cancellations and censorship targeting works or artists, and whose findings are cited to document the rise of these obstructions.

What does the obstruction offense written into the Criminal Code change?

Since 2016, it punishes only pressures that have actually prevented a creation or a performance, a condition that is hard to prove in the face of self-censorship or cuts in subsidies.

Why does this proposal matter?

It aims to protect cultural programming against political, ideological or religious pressures, while leaving intact the right to criticize a work or to call for a boycott.

Lire en français