The lagoon was a dumping ground for chemicals suspected to have included cancer-causing polychlorinated biphenyls, or PCBs, from Monsanto. The then Clwyd County Council bought the site for 1 pound in May 1980.
Steve Williams was among the first responders. He had followed his father into the fire service in 1978, and Wrexham was his first posting.
Eleven firefighters or their families have told a BBC investigation they fear a chemical lagoon fire in 1980 may have damaged their health.
The blaze was at the Llwyneinion lagoon, a dumping site for chemicals near Wrexham. Crews fought it for two days.
It was a sight that struck terror into those called out: a chemical waste lagoon on fire, with barrels exploding into the air.
Williams slipped into the lagoon and was pulled out. His widow thinks fluid he swallowed may have cost him his life. He died of a rare lung cancer at 39, 14 years after the fire.
Andy Moore, now 70, spent the day bringing in foam to help smother the flames and saw Williams fall in. Moore, also stationed at Wrexham, said crews were not equipped for the chemicals.
"There was no request for chemical PPE, we were basically fighting that fire in our normal tunics, drips and helmets,"Moore said.
Mark Jones, now 68, attended with his father, Ken. Ken later died of lymph and brain cancer in 2011."Out of the 60 people that attended that fire a significant number had cancers or passed away with cancer,"Mark Jones said.
Those who spoke to the investigation said partners of firefighters who attended had an increased number of miscarriages in the following year, and they raised concerns about cancer rates since. MacGrane said he could not tie every illness to the incident, but he saw too many coincidences, including colleagues who died young of cancer.
A firefighter identified as Jilska said he was checked at hospital after falling in, then given a tetanus injection and sent home.
The lagoon is still there, fenced off, which has worried some of the firefighters."The actual lagoon is still there from what I can make out in the same state it was 46 years ago,"Stuart Jones said. One firefighter called it a time bomb waiting to go off.
A leading expert in fire chemistry and toxicity said it was difficult to establish a link between firefighters' chemical exposure and health problems later in life."With firefighters it's even harder,"she added, because they can be exposed to"a cocktail of toxic substances"throughout their careers.
Tovey said he would write to Wales' fire and rescue services to ask what protections are in place today for crews sent to sites linked to historical dumping of toxic waste. A union representative said the potential of that happening again was very clear, and that the union was consulting scientists to"discuss what options we may have available to support"the retired firefighters in their search for answers.