After the off-field issues that have overshadowed the tour, this was a welcome, entertaining game. England, who came from 1-0 down in the recent one-day series, can level the contest on the Gold Coast on Tuesday.
Set 188 to win, a home side light on star names closed out the chase and took a 1-0 lead in the five-match series. The win offered relief after a bruising week dominated by the sandpaper scandal.
Chaudhary, 30, came in at No 4 and made 66 from 38 balls, going one better than England's captain and breaking the back of the chase in just his fourth outing for his adopted country.
Chaudhary has said he switched allegiance because he feels"more close to Australian culture than Indian culture". He stayed in Australia, worked through club cricket, and became the match-winner on Tuesday night.
His bowling had already hurt England. Two wickets, with just 21 runs in the column, helped derail an innings that reached 187 for nine, a record total on this ground and still light.
Sitting on 123 for five at the start of the 12th over, they grew wary of burning more resources and finished short of a safer total.
Brook accepted that England let the match slip with the bat. The innings started in chaos, promised plenty at halfway, then fizzled as Australia's spinners applied the squeeze.
Australia should have shut the danger down sooner. They granted lives on two and three and put down six catches in the innings.