sport

Review panel logs six Premier League referee mistakes

The KMI panel logged six refereeing mistakes from the last Premier League round, including only two missed VAR interventions, matching early 2023-24.

joint, premier league, friday, coventry city, everton, referee, weekend, league

Key facts

  • The count matters because the weekly results create a merit table that contributes to 50% of referees' salaries in bonus payments. That link is more…
  • A review panel logged six refereeing mistakes from the last round of Premier League matches, a total last recorded in the early part of the 2023-24 season.
  • Each week, the five members of the KMI panel assess all the contentious incidents. They vote on whether both the referee and the video assistant…

The count matters because the weekly results create a merit table that contributes to 50% of referees' salaries in bonus payments. That link is more important in the Premier League than elsewhere.

A review panel logged six refereeing mistakes from the last round of Premier League matches, a total last recorded in the early part of the 2023-24 season.

Each week, the five members of the KMI panel assess all the contentious incidents. They vote on whether both the referee and the video assistant referee got the decisions correct.

The first vote is on the referee's decision. That is treated as a basic judgement in law and in the Premier League's expected interpretation.

The review takes into account what the referee has said, the available replay angles and the high bar for a VAR intervention.

In the last round, almost every fixture had a contentious refereeing situation that was hotly debated. Given that controversy, it may come as a surprise that the panel ruled only two incidents were missed VAR interventions.

Many fans will feel there should have been more than two VAR errors logged. Some of the most high-profile decisions from the weekend have not yet featured.

Ipswich were awarded a 72nd-minute penalty against Bournemouth for a foul by Lewis Cook on Abdoul Ouattara. The panel said:"A penalty was incorrect with the contact being inevitable.".

The panel also said readily available footage did not provide conclusive evidence in one case, and that another incident"was not a clear and obvious error."On a separate incident it said:"On the balance of probability the ball did accidentally strike Barry's hand.".

Leeds United's Jayden Bogle caught Tottenham's Mathys Tel high on the ankle. Two panellists felt the challenge was sufficiently dangerous to merit a red card. One panellist felt the foul contact was inside the area.

Dig deeper

What is the Premier League?

It is England's top professional football division, where match officials' weekly performance ratings feed a merit table that can affect half of their bonus pay.

What is the KMI panel?

KMI stands for Key Match Incidents: a five-member review group that each week judges whether the referee and the video assistant referee handled disputed calls correctly.

Who are Ipswich and Bournemouth?

Ipswich Town and AFC Bournemouth are English clubs whose Premier League meeting produced a disputed 72nd-minute penalty that the panel later called incorrect.

Who is Lewis Cook?

Lewis Cook is a Bournemouth midfielder whose challenge on Abdoul Ouattara led to that penalty award.

What is a VAR intervention?

VAR is the video assistant referee, who may overturn an on-field call only when the evidence clears a high bar; the panel found just two missed interventions in the round.

Lire en français