politics

Prosecutors do not confirm 40 education staff complicity cases

The executive claims at least 40 complicity cases by National Education staff, yet prosecutor's offices contacted by franceinfo find almost none.

france, education, intérieur, assemblée, interpell, gouvernement, nationale, personnel

Key facts

  • Franceinfo turns to the judicial authorities. After contacting more than half of the 168 public prosecutors' offices, nearly all say they have no…
  • The gap is significant. The executive is accusing public employees of serious acts, up to and including supplying fireworks mortars to pupils, while…
  • This figure of at least 40 cases rests, according to the government, on testimony passed up to the authorities. The head of government guarantees…

Franceinfo turns to the judicial authorities. After contacting more than half of the 168 public prosecutors' offices, nearly all say they have no proceedings targeting staff of the National Education system for these acts. No prosecutor's office in the areas where mortar fire was reported has any such case under way.

The gap is significant. The executive is accusing public employees of serious acts, up to and including supplying fireworks mortars to pupils, while the prosecutors' offices contacted report no proceedings of this kind.

This figure of at least 40 cases rests, according to the government, on testimony passed up to the authorities. The head of government guarantees that this"tiny minority"of people will be prosecuted.

The minister persists on Wednesday, during questions to the government in the National Assembly. The education minister and the government spokesperson confirm, on Friday 13 November, the prime minister's statements.

The few cases reported by the judicial authorities have no connection with the supply of fireworks mortars to pupils. They concern teachers who are no longer in service or who acted outside the school setting.

In Nîmes, a 24-year-old trainee sports teacher at a middle school is sentenced in immediate appearance proceedings on 19 October"to 18 months' imprisonment, suspended with probation for two years,""for throwing projectiles at the police,"according to the prosecutor's office. The events take place"at the Nîmes-Ouest motorway roundabout,"during the day of mobilization against the high cost of living on 17 October, and not during a high-school blockade.

These cases do not, in any event, amount to the supply of fireworks mortars to high-school students by members of National Education staff.

The government therefore maintains an assessment based on testimony and announces prosecutions. The prosecutors' offices contacted, for their part, report neither complaints over the supply of mortars nor, in nearly all cases, proceedings targeting National Education staff for the acts described.

Dig deeper

What is a public prosecutor's office in France?

The public prosecutor's office is the prosecution service: it directs investigations, decides whether or not to bring charges, and represents the prosecution. It is therefore the body that can say whether there really are proceedings against National Education staff.

What is the National Assembly?

It is the chamber of deputies of the French Parliament. During questions to the government, ministers answer deputies there, the setting in which the figure of at least 40 cases was maintained.

Where is Nîmes located, and what does this case file show?

Nîmes is a city in the Gard, in southern France. The case cited there concerns a trainee teacher tried for throwing projectiles during a protest against the high cost of living, and not for having supplied mortars to high-school students.

What is a firework mortar?

It is a pyrotechnic device designed to project a charge. The executive refers to their being handed to pupils by public officials, a fact that the prosecutors' offices contacted do not link to any ongoing proceedings.

What is an immediate appearance?

It is a procedure that allows a person to be tried quickly after police custody, when the facts appear established and the case is ready to be tried.

What is National Education in this debate?

It is the public administration that employs teachers and staff in primary schools, middle schools and high schools. The government is implicating a "tiny minority" of them, without the prosecutors' offices contacted confirming prosecutions for the facts described.

Lire en français