politics

Philippe wants to reinstate compulsory national service

Édouard Philippe, mayor of Le Havre, on Wednesday unveiled compulsory national service among 142 measures, without saying which generations are concerned.

france, trente, horizons, malmen, philippe, service, national, présidentielle

Key facts

  • Édouard Philippe, mayor of Le Havre and Horizons candidate in the presidential election, unveiled his platform on Wednesday, November 18, at a news…
  • The candidate, struggling in the polls, remains bogged down in questions surrounding his participation in the primary of the right and the center. It…
  • The restoration of compulsory national service regularly returns in the platforms of presidential candidates. The proposal puts an old debate back at…

Édouard Philippe, mayor of Le Havre and Horizons candidate in the presidential election, unveiled his platform on Wednesday, November 18, at a news conference. Among the 142 measures is the restoration of compulsory national service, which disappeared nearly thirty years ago.

The candidate, struggling in the polls, remains bogged down in questions surrounding his participation in the primary of the right and the center. It was in this context that he presented his plan to the press.

The restoration of compulsory national service regularly returns in the platforms of presidential candidates. The proposal puts an old debate back at the heart of the campaign, even though the French army has been professional since the end of conscription.

In 2007, Ségolène Royal, then the Socialist candidate, proposed a six-month service. Durations and purposes differ from one candidate to another, but the principle of an obligation returns from one election to the next.

Military service, created in 1798 during the French Revolution, was long regarded as a symbol of social mixing. It is this republican ideal that the suspension set aside.

At the time, the decision relieved many young people and families who no longer really understood the usefulness of the service, the Cold War having ended.

The political class, on both the right and the left, was caught off guard. The president of the Republic wanted to professionalize the army: what France needed was not numbers, but an effective and modern defense.

Paradoxically, the military are more reserved about the compulsory nature of a national service. One objection recurs in the debate: imposing a service of several months by constraint could prove ineffective, all the more so in a modern army.

Cost is another obstacle that has already been quantified. According to a 2017 report by Senator Jean-Pierre Raffarin, restoring military service could cost 30 billion euros over five years and would require mobilizing nearly 18,000 supervisors.

Édouard Philippe did not say on Wednesday how such a service would fit with a professional army or which generations it would target. For now, the measure remains a political principle more than a detailed scheme.

Dig deeper

Who is Édouard Philippe?

Former prime minister (2017-2020), he is mayor of Le Havre and founder of Horizons, a center-right party of which he is the presidential candidate.

What is Horizons?

A political party created in 2021 by Édouard Philippe, rooted in the center right, whose candidacy he carries.

What is Le Havre?

A major port city in Normandy, in Seine-Maritime, of which Philippe is the mayor.

What was compulsory national service?

An obligation, born in 1798 during the Revolution, of a period under the colors long seen as a social mixing, suspended nearly thirty years ago in favor of a professional army.

Who is Ségolène Royal?

Socialist candidate in the 2007 presidential election, she then proposed a compulsory civic service of six months.

Why is this debate returning?

Since the professionalization of the army, the political class has hesitated between the republican ideal of compulsory service and the risk that a constraint of several months would be of little use to a modern defense.

Lire en français