The Manchester United Supporters’ Trust warned publicly in January 2025 that alienating fans risked a downward spiral in atmosphere, performances and finances. Treating loyal supporters chiefly as a source of revenue, it argued, undermines the identity that sustains the club through difficult periods.
Carrick’s departure is another low point for a side already under strain. United travel to Anfield in the Premier League four days later.
The discontent is not confined to results. Coverage of the club described a widening divide, with the bond between supporters, players and those running Manchester United under increasing pressure.
Inside the club, Wilcox is leading a review. Once that became known, the expectation was that he would recommend Ratcliffe dismiss Carrick. Observers described a vacuum at the top that someone still has to fill.
Discussion of the hierarchy has been sharp. One line of criticism is that United have been opportunistic in their managerial appointments, and that Carrick was treated poorly by those above him.
Pochettino would inherit that tension. At Chelsea he had clear friction with the club hierarchy, though the signs at United are that he could have the personality to build his own power base.
Even among those who see him as the favourite, there is caution. The same coverage warned that Pochettino may not be an instant cure for United’s malaise, and that the timing of any appointment will matter.