politics

Court convicts three officers and upholds racism against Zecler

On Friday, the Paris criminal court sentenced three police officers to one to two years' unsuspended prison for beating Michel Zecler and finding racism.

france, paris, jusqu, michel zecler la, michel zecler, michel, zecler, policiers

Key facts

  • The verdict is delivered after nearly twelve hours of waiting, before a very full courtroom. Among those present, most often in support of Michel…
  • The court identifies one of the officers as the one who initiated the check, then the unlawful attempt to arrest Michel Zecler. It finds that he…
  • The verdict, delivered in the evening before a large audience, upholds the aggravating circumstance of racism. That classification makes the alleged…

The verdict is delivered after nearly twelve hours of waiting, before a very full courtroom. Among those present, most often in support of Michel Zecler, the convictions spark fear and anger. The parents of Cédric Chouviat, who died during a police check in 2020 and who attended every day, are present for the verdict.

The court identifies one of the officers as the one who initiated the check, then the unlawful attempt to arrest Michel Zecler. It finds that he struck him on the skull with a telescopic baton, then kicked and punched him, and that he wrote the report falsifying the course of events.

The verdict, delivered in the evening before a large audience, upholds the aggravating circumstance of racism. That classification makes the alleged violence a felony, as the advocate general had requested.

The sentences remain far from the prosecution's recommendations. On Thursday, the prosecution had sought four to six years of unsuspended prison time against the three officers.

The penalties range from one year under electronic monitoring to two years of unsuspended imprisonment. A deferred committal order is issued for two of those convicted. The third serves his unsuspended sentence under electronic monitoring.

The court also imposes, against the three police officers, a permanent ban on serving as a police officer, with provisional enforcement, and therefore with immediate effect.

For one of them, the one-year unsuspended sentence is subject to provisional enforcement, but it may be served in the form of electronic monitoring. Those convicted, like the public prosecutor's office, have ten days to appeal.

It does, however, note his full acknowledgment of the facts and the apologies he offered at the hearing. It mentions the sense of insecurity that drove him at the time, after the 2015 attacks and the events linked to the yellow-vest movement.

Like the other two, this officer admitted at trial to having delivered unlawful blows. The three police officers, however, rejected any racism from the first day of the proceedings.

After the beating, the police officers drew up a false report accusing the producer of violence. That account is disproved by the studio's surveillance footage, which, according to the prosecution, saved Michel Zecler from a miscarriage of justice.

In finding racism, the court emphasizes that Michel Zecler told a Black police officer who was handcuffing him that he had been subjected to racist insults. He repeated this at the police station, during his transfer to the hospital, and then confided it to those close to him.

The representative of the public prosecutor's office had asked the court to believe Michel Zecler and also to recognize him as a victim of those insults. The court finds that the acts were of particular gravity, caused significant physical, psychological, and professional harm, and exposed him to a serious criminal risk.

Michel Zecler remains impassive on the civil parties' bench when the verdict is delivered. He is given a standing ovation as he leaves the courtroom.

Dig deeper

Who is Michel Zecler?

A Parisian music producer, he is the victim of the police violence tried in this case, which has become a symbol of contested identity checks and brutality.

Who is Cédric Chouviat?

A delivery worker who died in 2020 during a police check in Paris, his case is another emblematic police-violence case; his parents followed the Zecler trial.

What does the aggravating circumstance of racism change?

It increases the severity of the classification of the violence and, in this verdict, raises it to the level of a felony, as the prosecution had requested.

What is a detention order with deferred effect?

It is imprisonment ordered by the court but whose execution is postponed, in this case for two of the three convicted police officers.

What does the provisional enforcement of the ban on practicing the profession mean?

The permanent ban on being a police officer applies immediately, without waiting for a possible appeal.

What can those convicted do now?

They, like the public prosecutor's office, have ten days to appeal the verdict.

Lire en français