politics

Before midnight, interventions rise to denounce government measure

Senators unanimously reject, during the night from November 16 to November 17, the partial de-indexation of pensions provided for in the bill for 2027.

retraites, sénat, sécurit, travail jean, pierre farandou, pensions, indexation, inflation

Key facts

  • Senators unanimously rejected, during the night of 16 to 17 November, the partial de-indexation of pensions planned for 2027. They opposed the…
  • Highly sensitive politically, the measure represents 4 billion euros for the Social Security accounts. This first-reading vote is not final for the time being.
  • Through this article, the government proposed to depart from ordinary law and to forgo raising all retirement pensions in line with inflation. The…

Senators unanimously rejected, during the night of 16 to 17 November, the partial de-indexation of pensions planned for 2027. They opposed the freeze, next year, of pensions above 1,260 euros, set out in Article 35 of the Social Security financing bill (PLFSS).

Highly sensitive politically, the measure represents 4 billion euros for the Social Security accounts. This first-reading vote is not final for the time being.

Through this article, the government proposed to depart from ordinary law and to forgo raising all retirement pensions in line with inflation. The text limited automatic indexation to pensions of up to 1,260 euros a month.

A referral mechanism by decree was meant to leave the future government, in 2027, the option of quickly reversing this freeze if it wished. In the event of adoption under Article 49.3 of the Constitution, the executive would nonetheless retain the ability to maintain the measure.

The right-wing and centrist Senate majority had initially taken a different line. At its meeting on 4 November, it had agreed to defend a partial freeze of pensions in the chamber.

It wanted to protect more retirees than the government version, by raising pensions up to 1,500 euros, an amount close to the minimum wage. The Social Affairs Committee was then moving toward a slightly reduced effort.

Last week, LR and centrist senators ultimately decided to defend the indexation of all pensions as part of the examination of the PLFSS.

Notably, the government expressed a wisdom opinion on the Social Affairs Committee’s sole deletion amendment. It deferred to the senators’ vote, without opposing it, while firmly opposing the position of the Senate majority.

In the same budget review, senators deleted Article 34 of the 2027 Social Security budget. That article provided for converting the pension increase for parents of three children into a flat-rate sum.

Right-wing and centrist senators also symbolically restored the rise in the legal retirement age provided for by the 2023 reform. That rise had been suspended in the latest Social Security financing law, adopted at the end of 2025.

On the tax front, the Senate majority proposes the complete abolition of the 10% allowance applied to retirees for the calculation of income tax. The government’s text provides for lowering the ceiling of this allowance from 4,439 to 3,000 euros.

Dig deeper

What is the PLFSS?

The Social Security financing bill sets each year the revenue and spending of Social Security, including retirement pensions.

What is Social Security?

It is the French public system that finances, in particular, sickness, family benefits and pensions; the partial freeze on pensions would amount to 4 billion euros.

What does Article 49.3 of the Constitution mean?

It allows the government to adopt a text without a vote, unless a motion of no confidence is passed; the executive could then maintain the pension freeze.

What is the Smic?

It is the legal minimum wage in France; right-wing and centrist senators had initially wanted to index pensions up to a level close to that amount, namely 1,500 euros.

Is this Senate vote final?

No: it is a first-reading vote, and the text may still change before any eventual adoption.

Lire en français