Amnesty France fears, with the adoption of this presumption
Parliament adopted Friday a presumption of lawful use of weapons by law enforcement. Amnesty France fears it. Unsa Police says it is not a license to kill.
Pierre-Louis Crescitz
france, présomption, unsa police, le parlement, unsa, usage, légal, armes
Key facts
Parliament definitively adopts, on Friday, November 20, a bill that establishes a presumption of lawful use of weapons by law enforcement.
The text establishes that, when they use their weapons, police officers and gendarmes are presumed to have acted within the framework of the law.
This presumption concerns compliance with the legal framework for the use of a weapon. It can be reversed if proof to the contrary is provided.
Parliament definitively adopts, on Friday, November 20, a bill that establishes a presumption of lawful use of weapons by law enforcement.
The text establishes that, when they use their weapons, police officers and gendarmes are presumed to have acted within the framework of the law.
This presumption concerns compliance with the legal framework for the use of a weapon. It can be reversed if proof to the contrary is provided.
It details the possible follow-up to a contested use of a weapon: the magistrate goes to the scene if there is the beginning of evidence suggesting that the police officer did not act within the framework of self-defense. The officer is then placed in police custody.
Dig deeper
What is Amnesty France?
Amnesty International France is the French section of the non-governmental organization that defends human rights. It is named here because it fears the effects of this presumption on oversight of the use of weapons.
Which Parliament is involved?
It is the French Parliament, composed of the National Assembly and the Senate, the only institution empowered to definitively adopt a law.
Which law-enforcement forces are concerned?
The text concerns officers of the national police and gendarmes, two distinct forces authorized to carry a service weapon.
What does it mean to be able to reverse this presumption?
The presumption is not irrebuttable: if contrary evidence is produced, the police officer or gendarme is no longer considered to have acted within the legal framework.
What is legitimate self-defense in this context?
It is a legal ground that can justify the use of force, or even of a weapon, when it is necessary and proportionate to repel an unjustified attack.