Wattimena finished with an average of 101.70 and hit 10 scores of 180. For most of the contest his level was high enough that the winning margin could have been more comfortable.
The Dutchman, 38, is through to the quarter-finals for a second time. The defeat ends the tournament run of the 19-year-old world champion.
Wattimena was in tears after the win, which he had to close out after a late wobble.
For long stretches he looked imperious. He took six legs in a row to open a 7-2 lead.
He twice threatened nine-darters and had two darts for an 8-2 advantage. Littler was rarely given a look at a double.
The lead did not bring a routine finish. As the end of the match drew near, Wattimena showed signs of nerves.
Littler sensed the chance. He broke throw with a 10-darter as Wattimena stuttered a leg from victory.
The comeback fell just short. With Littler waiting to throw at 65, Wattimena hit double top to take out 77 and win the match.
"I think I played really incredible, I played my best game on this stage and I'm really proud of it,"an emotional Wattimena told Sky Sports.
He held off the world champion's late push to move into the last eight.