science

Top scientist warns delay to IPCC report threatens climate fight

A leading climate scientist warned that delaying the IPCC's next assessment could undermine the core Paris agreement and the next global stocktake.

paris, climate, changing, nacpil, guardian, ipcc, global, delay

Key facts

  • Nations will gather for Cop33, where the second global stocktake under the Paris agreement will be thrashed out. That stocktake is the mechanism by…
  • One of the world's leading climate scientists has warned that attempts to delay new scientific reports threaten global cooperation on the climate…
  • The next assessment, AR7, is the seventh in a series dating to 1988. It is under way, and it is hoped it will be completed in 2028.

Nations will gather for Cop33, where the second global stocktake under the Paris agreement will be thrashed out. That stocktake is the mechanism by which progress toward the core Paris goal, of limiting temperature rises to 1.5C above pre-industrial levels, will be judged.

One of the world's leading climate scientists has warned that attempts to delay new scientific reports threaten global cooperation on the climate crisis, and said climate science is foundational to the Paris agreement and to worldwide progress on global heating.

The next assessment, AR7, is the seventh in a series dating to 1988. It is under way, and it is hoped it will be completed in 2028.

Rockström said the IPCC brings together work done voluntarily by scientists from the entire world."The IPCC is the summary of everything done voluntarily by scientists from the entire world, global south and global north, that collectively carries out a synthesis,"he said.

Although the IPCC has cash reserves to draw on, there will be little chance of producing its reports before the stocktake if a budget cannot be agreed.

Rockström said that even if AR7 was delayed, the science in AR6 would be enough to show that current pledges, made last year before Cop30, must be vastly improved."Even if you based your updates only on AR6, we would still be making enormous progress,"he said.

In an interview with the Guardian at Cop31, he said the pathways to the future represent different socioeconomic realities around the world. He said the panel's work is an objective, evidence-based analysis of reality.

He said it represents the best peer-reviewed science of scientists' understanding of how to close income gaps in poor countries versus rich countries, of demographic changes and health projections, and of forecasts of socioeconomic development.

Many other developing countries, including small islands and the least developed countries, have called for the IPCC report to be completed without delay. Others fear a delay could be used by countries to derail the global stocktake, for instance by arguing that it too must be delayed or modified.

They argue, with the backing of some climate campaigners, that developing countries are disadvantaged in trying to submit science to the IPCC. Nacpil said changing the assumptions would produce different scenarios.

The IPCC said that of 664 appointed authors working on the drafts of its three working group reports, 51% came from developing countries and economies in transition. That was an increase of almost half compared with the last report in 2021.

Each chapter across the three reports includes at least one developing-country chapter scientist. The core committees of the IPCC are run by pairs of scientists, one from a developed country and one from a developing country.

In the current cycle, the IPCC introduced institutional measures that implement equity and inclusivity. A spokesperson said:"IPCC is absolutely committed to promoting diversity and inclusion and has taken multiple steps to do so during its seventh cycle.".

"As the UN body assessing the science related to climate change, we uphold and stand by the core values of integrity, professionalism and respect for diversity and gender,"the spokesperson said.

Technically, the issues cannot be solved at a Cop, because they can only be agreed within the IPCC itself. As governments meet in Turkey, some form of compromise may be possible.

Rockström said the panel is objective, evidence-based science and"the only thing that we can reliably stand on as a basis for our policymaking."He added:"What we need to do in this process is really respect the science.".

He said science should not be used as the arena to fight for justice or human rights or even democracy."We have to defend that objective science,"he said.

Dig deeper

Who is Rockström?

Johan Rockström is a Swedish Earth-system scientist who leads the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research and is known for the planetary-boundaries framework used in climate policy debates.

What is the Paris agreement?

It is the 2015 global climate treaty whose core temperature goal is to hold warming to 1.5C above pre-industrial levels, with countries updating national pledges over time.

What is the IPCC?

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change is the UN body that synthesizes peer-reviewed climate science from researchers worldwide into assessment reports used by governments.

What is AR7?

AR7 is the IPCC's seventh assessment report, a series that began in 1988; work is under way with completion hoped for in 2028, in time to inform the next stocktake if funding is agreed.

What is the global stocktake?

It is the Paris agreement process in which countries collectively judge progress toward the 1.5C goal; the second stocktake is due to be negotiated at Cop33.

What is Cop33?

Cop33 is the next major UN climate conference after Cop30 and Cop31, where governments are expected to thrash out that second global stocktake.

Lire en français