politics

"This scandalizes me": creators react to Arcom pluralism rules

Arcom announced on Thursday, November 19, pluralism rules for the 2027 presidential election, extended for the first time to major online creators.

arcom, jean massiet, backseat, internet, pluralisme, créateurs, politique, scandalise

Key facts

  • For the first time, leading content creators on YouTube and social media will be required to respect pluralism in their coverage of the presidential…
  • Jean Massiet, host of the talk show Backseat and another prominent political figure on social media, does not share that view. He refuses to invite…
  • The regulator has issued the rules intended to ensure pluralism in the media over the coming months. The first debates ahead of the 2027 presidential…

For the first time, leading content creators on YouTube and social media will be required to respect pluralism in their coverage of the presidential election, on the same basis as television and radio. The Regulatory Authority for Audiovisual and Digital Communication (Arcom) announced this on Thursday, November 19.

Jean Massiet, host of the talk show Backseat and another prominent political figure on social media, does not share that view. He refuses to invite the far right onto his program and denounces the measure as an infringement of freedom of expression.

The regulator has issued the rules intended to ensure pluralism in the media over the coming months. The first debates ahead of the 2027 presidential election have already taken place.

Until now, the standard obligations of fairness, and then of equal speaking time, applied to television and radio. This year, Arcom is also announcing measures applicable to the internet and its content creators.

The stakes are immediate: these players are increasingly present on the political stage and are multiplying meetings with candidates. Arcom wants to guarantee pluralism on the internet.

The reasoning recalled on this occasion rests on a technical particularity. Television and radio have a limited number of broadcast channels. Pluralism rules are required during an election campaign, otherwise candidates could be excluded from the media landscape.

On the internet and in the print press, by contrast, there is no maximum limit on the number of channels. It is on this point that the regulator’s decision divides the creators concerned.

The idea is drawing widely varied reactions. One of the most followed political YouTubers explains that he has chosen to give everyone a voice, setting aside his personal convictions and without seeking to impose them on his community.

In recent years, he has hosted political figures from across the spectrum. Pluralism, he says in substance, is something he already practices.

He pledges to cover the legal costs of creators who may be targeted by Arcom. In his view, these broadcasters make editorial choices in complete freedom, and nothing justifies imposing such obligations on them.

In this debate, it is also recalled that citizens have the right to interview whichever presidential candidates they wish. Arcom, for its part, places pluralism at the center of the rules it has just set for the months ahead.

Dig deeper

What is Arcom?

The French Regulatory Authority for Audiovisual and Digital Communication is France's regulator of television, radio and, increasingly, online content. It sets, among other things, the rules on pluralism during election periods.

Who is Jean Massiet?

Jean Massiet is a widely followed political content creator and host of the talk show Backseat, who refuses to invite the far right and sees the new rules as an infringement of freedom of expression.

What is Backseat?

Backseat is the political talk show hosted by Jean Massiet on social media, one of the formats affected by the extension of pluralism rules to creators.

Why were television and radio already regulated?

Their broadcast channels are limited: without rules of fairness and then of equal speaking time, candidates could be excluded from the campaign debate.

Why is the extension to the internet divisive?

On the internet, the number of channels is not capped, an argument long raised against pluralism obligations comparable to those of broadcasting, even as creators carry greater weight in the 2027 presidential election.

Lire en français