The card of Ukrainian membership in NATO is thus put back into play. In the approach openly assumed by the Élysée, it serves to structure a negotiation that remains hypothetical, and it has already produced the desired effect: an unequivocal reaction from Moscow to the mere mention of the Alliance.
The mere mention of NATO in a negotiation over a hypothetical ceasefire in Ukraine was enough to provoke an unequivocal reaction from Moscow. The Alliance, barely named, has thus regained a place in an exchange whose outcome remains uncertain.
This Western argument was intended to provoke, and it hit its mark. Moscow's unequivocal reaction measures the effect of this mere reference: placing NATO in talks that are still hypothetical was enough to obtain a Russian response that leaves no room for maneuver.
The ceasefire in question is not presented as secured. What is, at this stage, stems from the Élysée's choice: to structure the negotiation while openly assuming the reopening of the debate on membership, in the face of a Russia that has already responded unequivocally.