Since the outbreak of war in 2022, the Kremlin has kept wealthy businessmen in line with a ruthless policy of carrot and stick. Critics of the war have seen their assets seized, while loyalists have been rewarded with lavish government war contracts.
There are more Russian billionaires than ever: 155 in total, according to Forbes magazine. Their collective wealth has reached a new high of nearly $700bn (£525bn).
Even if any of the tycoons objected to the war, they have tended to keep their thoughts to themselves. That silence has become a feature of the Russian super-rich.
Quietly, some of their minds are turning to what happens after Putin leaves the scene. They are wondering whether the country might look more like it did in the 1990s, or whether a healthier politics may take root.
"They'd like to return to a time when they were listened to, when they were not stripped of assets and when they understood the rules of the game,"said Prokopenko, who has spent a lot of time speaking to Russia's richest people.
Prokopenko said there has already been a shift in how the businessmen talk about Putin. Melnichenko did not call for Putin to go, but he argued for a change that would bring an end to one-man rule in Russia.
He said Russia needs to engage more with the world. Prokopenko thinks the tycoon was trying to stir a public conversation, and that he seemed to be"genuinely thinking"about his answers rather than giving politician-style spin.
Though their power has been seriously curtailed since the 1990s, it is still worth listening to the tycoons. Given their immense wealth, it seems likely that sooner or later they will try to reassert their political influence.
One possibility is that a different figure replaces Putin and continues his culture of repression. Key democratic institutions have been eroded or destroyed over his rule.
At the moment, she said, they are too afraid to make that happen because of Russia's stifling atmosphere. These things take time: at first, Putin's successor would be weaker than him, with fewer resources.
That would create something of a power vacuum. A third option, and the one many tycoons want, is that they reassert their power and Russia returns to something resembling a 1990s-style system of oligarchy.
The collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 gave birth to people who took advantage of the end of communism, became extraordinarily rich, and then wanted to control politicians for their own benefit.
He had little interest in sharing power with anyone else. He could afford to stand up to the billionaires because Russia's economy was getting back on its feet and the central government was getting stronger.
At one meeting, Putin sat at the opposite side of the hall, creating a vast space between him and the businessmen."And then Putin showed up, and it was just remarkable to see how these supposedly alpha-male-on-steroids individuals turned into absolutely subordinate, almost desperate schoolchildren,"one account given to the BBC said.
"It must be very awful and humiliating for them,"said Browder, an avowed Putin critic. Analysts say the businessmen are rich because they have something to do with Putin, not the other way round.
Dmitry Nekrasov, a former Kremlin adviser and opposition politician who now lives in exile, said that under one scenario the country would be governed by a handful of powerful elite clans in alliance with business interests.
The caution is physical as well as political. Prokopenko interviewed one tycoon who sat on his phone throughout the conversation, because he thought that would make digital eavesdropping more difficult for the secret police.