world

European clubs' world plan puts Fifa on tenterhooks

Europe's club body is studying a move into global competitions, a plan that could shift power and money toward the richest clubs as Fifa watches.

europe, european, fifa, findings, gianni infantino, football, global, plan

Key facts

  • Those who defend the present balance note that Europe generates about 70% of Fifa's revenue. On that reading, a larger European share follows the…
  • The European clubs' body, EFC, is examining how to enter the international football market as a competition organiser, and the findings of a…
  • Whatever the outcome, Europe's wealthiest clubs are certain to benefit. Some leading figures in the sport's governance believe the study could define…

Those who defend the present balance note that Europe generates about 70% of Fifa's revenue. On that reading, a larger European share follows the money the continent already produces.

The European clubs' body, EFC, is examining how to enter the international football market as a competition organiser, and the findings of a feasibility study into that drive are among the most eagerly awaited papers in the game, if they are ever fully revealed.

Whatever the outcome, Europe's wealthiest clubs are certain to benefit. Some leading figures in the sport's governance believe the study could define football's long-term future.

The study is not alone in carrying huge implications for the shape of the game. While one shift is already under way, another will not be far behind.

Fifa said last month that it would hand over an additional $2.7bn (£2.05bn) from its reserves over the next four years, raising its total investment to $6.35bn (£4.83bn). That transfer of money is already in motion.

Solidarity payments are also skewed toward Europe. European clubs will receive 50% of a $250m pot even though they provide only 12 of the 32 contestants.

EFC was once seen as a lobby group speaking for clubs against domineering governing bodies. It has since grown into a body of almost 1,000 members with the potential, critics say, to supplant those bodies.

Sources familiar with EFC's intentions say it is looking at a role as organiser of international competitions and has floated the idea of more effective tournaments in different formats.

Some with a close interest in the process say the wish to expand is in plain sight and natural. Players and domestic leagues, they point out, already have their own global representative bodies.

The contents of a joint venture have caused particular concern inside Uefa. Its hierarchy are believed to have made clear that they do not want a deal between EFC and Fifa rushed through in the current climate.

"You're starting to see one of the major unspoken fault lines in football open up,"one source said of EFC's relationship with Uefa. The two sides have grown structurally closer in recent years, but the relationship is still conducted with high mutual caution.

A senior source at another confederation said the inevitable result of the joint venture would be less money for the rest of the world, certainly in proportional terms.

Beyond a sharp rise in funding for member associations, many senior figures in football have said the biggest long-term consequence of FFE's failure will be to increase the power of the biggest European clubs.

"The most significant long-term result of the Fifa crisis will be to entrench the economic might of the biggest European clubs,"they said. The world's wealthiest clubs, on that view, stand to gain from the crisis more handsomely than anyone else.

"It's not a matter of whether Gianni wins, but what his mandate is, and who is behind it?"a senior source in European football said. One stark assessment holds that EFC is going to take over Fifa in the same way it took over Uefa.

EFC has stayed silent on the presidential election and other governance issues. In the reading offered alongside that silence, the quiet is a sign that an agreement with Fifa has already been reached.

European clubs are cast by supporters of the move as well organised and economically rational, and as having taken the chance to extract something from Fifa. For the rest of the game, the open question is how much of football's future that extraction will decide.

Dig deeper

What is Fifa?

Fifa is world football's governing body, based in Zurich, and it runs the World Cup and other international tournaments whose commercial income funds much of the global game.

What is EFC?

EFC is the European clubs' body named in the piece, now described as having almost 1,000 members and exploring a role as an organiser of international competitions rather than only a lobby for clubs.

What are solidarity payments?

Solidarity payments are money redistributed from major tournaments to clubs, and in this case a $250m pot is split so European clubs get half even though they supply only 12 of 32 teams.

Why does Europe's share of the money matter?

Defenders of the status quo say Europe already generates about 70% of Fifa's revenue, so a larger European cut is framed as following where the money is made, while critics see it as further tilting power toward the richest clubs.

What is at stake if EFC becomes a competition organiser?

A feasibility study into that role is treated as potentially reshaping who runs international football, with Europe's wealthiest clubs expected to gain whichever way the findings land.

Lire en français