technology

Dutch watchdog tells people not to buy AI smart glasses

The Dutch privacy watchdog tested six AI smart glasses and told people not to buy them after false ambulance claims, privacy risks and security flaws.

dutch, tests, meta, previously, meanwhile, glasses, smart, dutch watchdog

Key facts

  • Meta, a leading seller of smart glasses, has highlighted the assistance the technology can provide to people with visual impairments. It recently…
  • The Dutch data protection authority has told people not to buy AI smart glasses after tests found failures that it said could put users and bystanders at risk.
  • The authority, the AP, tested six pairs sold on the Dutch market. It stopped short of calling for a ban on sales, but said consumers should not buy the devices.

Meta, a leading seller of smart glasses, has highlighted the assistance the technology can provide to people with visual impairments. It recently released a version without a camera. Some commentators suggested that move was a response to a privacy backlash.

The Dutch data protection authority has told people not to buy AI smart glasses after tests found failures that it said could put users and bystanders at risk.

The authority, the AP, tested six pairs sold on the Dutch market. It stopped short of calling for a ban on sales, but said consumers should not buy the devices.

In the tests, glasses misread instructions inside medicine packages and made errors when interpreting severe weather warnings, the AP said.

During a simulated emergency in which a user asked for CPR advice, one pair repeatedly claimed an ambulance was on the way. Emergency services had not been contacted.

The AP said one pair gave dating advice to an adult who indicated a romantic interest in a minor.

The authority did not name the brands it tested. It said the glasses came from different continents and ranged in price from under 100 euros (84 pounds) to more than 500 euros. It is not known whether the tests included glasses made by Meta.

The AP said lights meant to show that a device is recording could easily be obscured. With some glasses, it said, the lights could be covered with tape and the devices would still work, despite claims by some manufacturers that they would not function.

In some glasses, the AP found serious security flaws. It said someone nearby could connect without permission, view recordings, or operate the camera remotely.

The AP said the glasses can still be valuable for people who need help to understand their surroundings. The devices use AI to describe things in the wearer's environment or to read text.

The BBC has approached Meta, TCL and HTC, all major manufacturers of smart glasses, for comment. The firms have previously been keen to highlight positive uses of the devices.

Dig deeper

What is the AP?

The AP (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens) is the Netherlands' data protection authority, which enforces privacy rules and tested six pairs of AI smart glasses sold on the Dutch market.

What is Meta?

Meta is the company behind Facebook and Instagram and a leading seller of camera-equipped smart glasses; it is not known whether its products were among those the AP tested.

Why does the recording-light finding matter?

Indicator lights are meant to warn bystanders that a camera is on, but the AP found some could be covered with tape while the glasses kept working.

What is at stake for users and bystanders?

Faulty AI answers on medicine labels, severe weather and CPR, plus hidden recording, can mislead wearers and expose people nearby without clear notice.

Did the watchdog ban the glasses?

No. It stopped short of calling for a sales ban and instead told consumers not to buy the devices.

Lire en français