technology

BBC test shows mixed AI results on Black Friday TV deals

BBC reporters asked four free AI tools to find a 55-inch TV deal a week before Black Friday and got mixed, often outdated or mismatched recommendations.

black friday, retailers, crucially, hisense, chinese, friday, black, deals

Key facts

  • Another TCL option was at full price, £150 over budget, and not available online. A Sony suggestion was only 50 inches, leaving reporters unsure why…
  • BBC reporters asked the free versions of four popular AI tools to find a 55-inch television deal a week before Black Friday, and the results were mixed.
  • The test was meant to see whether the chatbots could save money on a new TV. Reporters used free versions of many of the most widely used tools.

Another TCL option was at full price, £150 over budget, and not available online. A Sony suggestion was only 50 inches, leaving reporters unsure why it had been included.

BBC reporters asked the free versions of four popular AI tools to find a 55-inch television deal a week before Black Friday, and the results were mixed.

The test was meant to see whether the chatbots could save money on a new TV. Reporters used free versions of many of the most widely used tools.

A YouGov survey of 19 countries found that the UK ranked second-last in the share of people who said they had used AI to help them shop.

Among respondents who said they would be shopping around Black Friday, 36% did not plan to use an AI tool at all.

Gemini generated a table comparing four models but offered no links to the stores it named, so reporters searched for the sets themselves.

Claude produced the shortest answer of the models tested and, unlike the others, gave little detail on the specifications of each set.

One tool's top pick was a Hisense television on the Chinese retailer Joybuy, listed at £499, down from £649.

Another top recommendation was a Samsung model at £616, down from £749, based on its picture quality and its Amazon customer rating.

A further suggestion was a 55-inch TCL set, but a sidebar showed prices for the 50-inch version, from £379 to £814.

Prices for one TCL television were correct at £649, but the set was sold out at one of the named retailers.

Different tools returned the same manufacturers, including Hisense and TCL, though not always the same models. The same brands appeared again and again, even as many more products were listed for sale around Black Friday.

Alexa did acknowledge the limits of its suggestions, encouraging users to check rivals for better deals"as prices can vary", and said longer guarantees might be available elsewhere.

One buyer later purchased one of seven models ChatGPT had surfaced, but found it for a lower price in a bricks-and-mortar shop.

Dig deeper

What is Black Friday?

Black Friday is the late-November shopping event, the day after US Thanksgiving, when retailers in the UK and elsewhere advertise steep discounts on goods such as televisions.

What is Gemini?

Gemini is Google's AI chatbot. In this test its free version compared TV models but did not link to the stores it named.

What is Claude?

Claude is the AI assistant from Anthropic. Its free version gave the shortest reply and little detail on each set's specifications.

What is Sony?

Sony is a Japanese electronics company known for televisions. One AI suggestion was a 50-inch Sony set, smaller than the 55-inch size requested.

What is Joybuy?

Joybuy is a Chinese online retailer. One tool's top pick was a Hisense TV listed there at £499, down from £649.

What is YouGov?

YouGov is a public-opinion research firm. Its survey of 19 countries found the UK near the bottom for people who said they had used AI to help them shop.

Lire en français