technology

Apple counters these accusations with the design of its products

Apple will stand trial in June 2027 in Paris, accused of having forced its customers, between 2021 and 2024, to have their phones repaired in its stores.

france, paris, apple, systématiquement, pièce, juin, téléphone, clients

Key facts

  • The American giant Apple will be tried in June 2027 before the Paris criminal court. The hearing is to examine the repair of its phones and the…
  • Apple counters these accusations with the design of its products."At Apple, we seek to design durable products, accompanied by software updates,"the…
  • According to the association suing Apple, the company allegedly forced its customers, between 2021 and 2024, to have repairs carried out in its own…

The American giant Apple will be tried in June 2027 before the Paris criminal court. The hearing is to examine the repair of its phones and the constraints alleged against the manufacturer.

Apple counters these accusations with the design of its products."At Apple, we seek to design durable products, accompanied by software updates,"the company said.

According to the association suing Apple, the company allegedly forced its customers, between 2021 and 2024, to have repairs carried out in its own stores. This imposed choice is at the center of the proceedings.

Apple is also accused of having blocked certain phone functions when a part was replaced by a repairer outside its authorized network. The manufacturer disputes these allegations, which it considers unfounded.

Critics describe tight control over every intervention. Repairing an Apple product would require going through a software step, checking the compatibility of parts and, sometimes, buying components exclusively from the manufacturer.

A comparison with other brands is also put forward. For those devices, parts can be purchased from the manufacturer, in a generic version or second-hand. This option is presented as more open than the circuit described at Apple.

The hearing is set before the Paris criminal court in June 2027. The judges will have to assess facts which, according to the association, span from 2021 to 2024, with no decision yet having been rendered.

Dig deeper

What is Apple in this case?

Apple is the American company that designs and sells iPhones, accused here of having restricted, between 2021 and 2024, the repair of its phones outside its network.

What is the Paris criminal court?

It is the Paris criminal court that tries misdemeanors; in June 2027 it will examine the repair restrictions alleged against Apple.

What does the blocking of functions after a part is replaced mean?

The association says an Apple phone can lose certain functions if a part is replaced outside the authorized network, which the manufacturer disputes.

Why does this case matter?

It pits Apple's control over parts, software and repairers against customers' right to have their phones repaired elsewhere, including with generic or used parts.

What happens next?

The hearing is set for June 2027 in Paris; no ruling has yet been issued on facts presented as spanning 2021 to 2024.

Lire en français